Keep the profile. Share something else

This is not a competitor comparison — you need both. It is about which one belongs in your Instagram bio, and the answer is not the one that shows three nearby alternatives.

What Google Business Profile is good at

Being found. It is free, authoritative, it is what ranks in Maps and local search, and its reviews are the ones that matter most. Every business should have one and keep it complete — a review page is not a substitute for it.

Where it leaves you stuck

Being shared. A Maps link drops the visitor into Google's interface, with competitors listed nearby and your branding nowhere. You cannot choose what it emphasises, and you cannot put your menu, your photos and one call to action above the fold.

Your profile is for being found; a page is for being shared

Nothing here replaces the Business Profile. Keep it complete, keep collecting Google reviews, keep replying. The page is where you send the people who already know your name.

What a Maps link actually shows a stranger

A pin, an interface they have to scroll, and a "people also search for" row of your competitors. It is a good product doing its own job, which is not the same as your job.

Reviews still belong on Google

Collect them there — that is what feeds local ranking and what strangers search. The page is where those reviews get seen by everyone who is not searching Maps.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will this hurt my Google ranking?

No. You keep collecting reviews on Google exactly as before. A page you link from elsewhere does not compete with your profile.

Can I use the page as my website link on Google?

Yes, and many businesses without a site do. Make sure it carries your key details: what you do, hours, location, contact.

What if my profile is suspended?

Then the page is the only place your reviews are still visible, which is a good argument for having one before you need it.

Read more on this